It’s a sterling cast, capably guided through the motions by director Thaddeus O’Sullivan in this at times gently amusing and at other times modestly touching dramedy. – Michael O’Sullivan, Washington Post

Director Thaddeus O’Sullivan and principal screenwriter Jimmy Smallhorne, both products of Irish neighborhoods like the one in the movie, infuse “The Miracle Club” with a sense of genuine authenticity. – Soren Andersen, Seattle Times

The idea of people’s past deeds coming back to haunt them is a familiar dramatic trope, but there’s nothing cliched in the treatment here. – Mick LaSalle, San Francisco Chronicle